Senior officials inside the Ford government planned to keep letters to cabinet members about their mandates secret as long as they could, a CBC News freedom of information request reveals.
The request was denied by the cabinet office, which claimed disclosing the records would “reveal the substance of the executive council or its committees.”
But in an email dated July 31, 2018 obtained by CBC News, the executive director of policy to the premier suggests it was the government’s position to keep the letters from public view.
“Here’s the letters. As I said, the intention is to keep them to ourselves as long as possible,” Greg Harrington said in the email to the chief of staff’s senior policy adviser, Derek O’Toole.
O’Toole’s response: “Thanks Greg ! Understood ????. ”
Exemption doesn’t apply: privacy commissioner
The revelation comes after Ontario’s information and privacy commissioner Brian Beamish disclosed the government plans to go to court to prevent the release of the letters to CBC News.
“There is no persuasive evidence or argument before me that disclosure (of the letters) would give rise to a chilling effect on cabinet deliberations …To a great extent, the mandate letters bear a close resemblance to the detailed policy platforms often produced by political parties during election campaigns,” Beamish said in his ruling.
In a blog posted Wednesday, Beamish explained that after reviewing the mandate letters, he determined they did not reveal government deliberations, the substance of any meetings or discussions by the premier’s office.
“The purpose of our freedom of information law is to support the public’s ‘right to know.’ Unless government records are exempt, they should be disclosed to the public. In this case, the mandate letters do not qualify for exemption as cabinet documents,” he said, adding he directed the cabinet office to disclose the letters by Aug. 16.
Beamish learned of court challenge Aug. 14
“I ordered their release because Ontarians have a right to know what the government’s policy priorities are,” he said.
Instead, on Aug. 14, Beamish said, he learned the government planned to take his office to court to prevent the letters from being released.
Mandate letters are commonly used by provincial governments across the country. Every other premier who issues them not only makes the letters public as a matter of course, they also publish them online as a deliberate way to allow the public to understand what the government plans to accomplish during its term.
After the cabinet officer first denied the request for the letters, CBC News sought an interview with Ford about the decision. Instead, then spokesperson Simon Jefferies sent a statement, which said in part that every Ontario government before Kathleen Wynne’s had kept its mandate letters private.
But a senior adviser to former premier Dalton McGuinty told CBC News that McGuinty’s government was the first to make the letters publicly available. Lloyd Rang, McGuinty’s former communications director, said that based on his recollection, such letters have been available either by public release or through requests for at least a decade in Ontario.
Province claims letters reflect cabinet deliberations
The federal government too has taken the position that mandate letters from the prime minister should be made public. Justin Trudeau released his mandate letters to cabinet ministers when his government was elected in November 2015.
In a statement to CBC News Wednesday, a spokesperson for the Ford government says it has filed an application for judicial review of the commissioner’s order before the Ontario Divisional Court.
“Our position is that the Premier’s mandate letters reflect the deliberations of Cabinet and are exempt from disclosure under FIPPA,” said Ivana Yelich.
“As this matter is currently before the Courts we cannot comment in detail on the Judicial Review proceedings.”
The CBC intends to continue its efforts to obtain the mandate letters so the public can find out what’s in them. A date for a hearing has not yet been set.